Thursday, December 19, 2019

Images of Ancient Equestrian Monuments in Rome

Nicoletta da Modena
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback 
(Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
ca. 1500-1510
engraving
British Museum

Antico (Pier Jacopo Alari Bonacolsi)
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback
(reduced copy)
ca. 1500-1510
bronze statuette
Liechtenstein Museum, Vienna

Marco da Ravenna
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback
(Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
ca. 1517-19
engraving
British Museum

"Apart from the groups of Alexander and Bucephalus [below], the Marcus Aurelius [above] was the most important statue to survive unburied from antiquity, and during the Middle Ages it attracted a number of fanciful legends and a wide variety of names.  By far the most important of these was that of Constantine for – as Carlo Fea pointed out in 1784 – it was probably due to this association with Christianity that it survived virtually intact after the downfall of paganism and the collapse of the Western Empire.  However, by the late twelfth century the name of Constantine was repeatedly refuted (though it lingered on for several hundred years more) and the statue was identified (probably for political reasons) with various heroes of the ancient Roman Republic – either Marcus Curtius whose valour in plunging into a chasm in order to save the State had been celebrated by Livy, or a heroic peasant (villano) or a warrior (armiger), whose deeds were variously recorded but who was credited with having captured a foreign king besieging Rome 'during the time of the consuls and senators'.  For this he had been rewarded with the equestrian statue which he had asked for.  It showed him with his arm outstretched to seize the king while a cuckoo sat on the horse's head – this was a misinterpretation of the foretop of the horse's mane – because that bird's cry had signalled the whereabouts of the king, while the king himself, reduced to the size of a dwarf and his hands tied behind his back, lay underfoot (as, no doubt, had some bound barbarian captive when the statue was in its original state).  A visitor to Rome early in the thirteenth century explained that one or other of these stories (with some variations) was believed by the Cardinals and officials of the Curia, while pilgrims thought that the figure was Theodoric and the people clung to the name of Constantine.  In the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries various emperors were proposed: Septimius Severus, Lucius Verus, Antoninus Pius, and Hadrian among them.  The humanist Bartolomeo Platina, who became librarian to Sixtus IV, is credited with having been the first to suggest Marcus Aurelius, but it was not until about 1600 that this became almost universally accepted."

– Francis Haskell and Nicholas Penny, Taste and the Antique (Yale University Press, 1981)

Hendrik Goltzius
Statue Group of Alexander and Bucephalus, or, Horse Tamer 
(Piazza del Quirinale, Rome)
1590-91
drawing
Teylers Museum, Haarlem

Hendrik Goltzius
Statue Group of Alexander and Bucephalus, or, Horse Tamer
(Piazza del Quirinale, Rome)
1590-91
drawing
Teylers Museum, Haarlem

"These two huge groups [above] were recorded standing on the Quirinal Hill in the popular pilgrims' guide to Rome, the Mirabilia Urbis Romae, which was composed in the mid-twelfth century and copied with variations and additions for several centuries.  It is almost certain that they had remained standing there since antiquity (for neither the machinery nor the motivation existed to move them, or to erect them, had they been excavated).  . . .  Although both horses were much repaired they seem to have been more admired than their superhuman companions in most Renaissance accounts of the group.  The men are sometimes described as naked slaves in attendance on the horses and are often not mentioned at all, and the Quirinal Hill was, after all, named Monte Cavallo after the horses.  However, in the first years of the eighteenth century, it was possible for de Blainville to declare the excellence of the horses was 'only perceptible to a Parcel of Italian Pedants', and thereafter it was typical of travellers to ignore or disparage the horses and to admire the men."

– Francis Haskell and Nicholas Penny, Taste and the Antique (Yale University Press, 1981)

Anonymous Artist working in Rome
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback 
(now in Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
16th century
drawing
Morgan Library, New York

Anonymous Italian Sculptor
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback 
(reduced copy)
ca. 1875
bronze statuette
Royal Collection, Great Britain

Francesco Faraone Aquila
Statue Group of Alexander and Bucephalus, or, Horse Tamer
(Piazza del Quirinale, Rome)
ca. 1704
engraving
British Museum

Francesco Faraone Aquila
Statue Group of Alexander and Bucephalus, or, Horse Tamer
(Piazza del Quirinale, Rome)
ca. 1704
engraving
Victoria & Albert Museum

Anonymous Photographer
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback 
(Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
ca. 1850-70
photograph
Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam

Anonymous Photographer
Statue of Marcus Aurelius on Horseback 
(Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
ca. 1880-1904
albumen print
Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam

Bartolomeo Pinelli
Pair of Statue Groups of Alexander and Bucephalus, or, The Horse Tamers
(Piazza del Quirinale, Rome)
1819
drawing
Philadelphia Museum of Art

Ostroumova-Lebedeva-Anna-
Pair of Statue Groups of Alexander and Bucephalus, or, The Horse Tamers
(Piazza del Quirinale, Rome)
1911
watercolor and gouache
Hermitage, Saint Petersburg

The two colossal statue groups with horses usually known as The Dioscuri (Castor and Pollux) [below] did not, like the others statues in this post, survive from antiquity above ground, but were "dug up during the pontificate of Pius IV in about 1560 and set up on either side of the entrance to the Capitol where Pope Paul III had intended moving the Quirinal statues."

Jan Asselijn
Pair of Statue Groups - the Dioscuri with Horses - flanking head of Staircase 
(Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
ca. 1635-42
drawing
British Museum

M.C. Escher
Statue Group - one of the Dioscuri, with Horse
(Piazza del Campidoglio, Rome)
1934
wood-engraving
National Gallery of Canada