Wednesday, August 29, 2018

French Subjects from the Nineteenth Century

follower of Jacques-Louis David
Portrait of an Elderly Lady
ca. 1820
oil on canvas
Walters Art Museum, Baltimore

Honoré Daumier
The Prison Choir
ca.1860
oil on panel
Walters Art Museum, Baltimore

Honoré Daumier
The Loge
ca. 1856-57
oil on panel
Walters Art Museum, Baltimore

Edgar Degas
Degas's Father listening to Lorenzo Pagans playing the Guitar
ca. 1869-72
oil on canvas
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Edgar Degas
Portrait of the Duchessa di Montejasi (Degas's Aunt Fanny) and her daughters Elena and Camilla
ca. 1876
oil on canvas
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

"The feminine character, and the ideal of femininity on which it is modelled, are products of masculine society.  The image of undistorted nature arises only in distortion, as its opposite.  Where it claims to be humane, masculine society imperiously breeds in women its own corrective, and shows itself through this limitation implacably the master.  The feminine character is a negative imprint of domination.  But therefore equally bad.  Whatever is in the context of bourgeois delusion about nature, is merely the scar of social mutilation.  If the psychoanalytical theory is correct that women experience their physical constitution as a consequence of castration, their neurosis gives them an inkling of the truth.  The woman who feels herself wounded when she bleeds knows more about herself than the one who imagines herself a flower because that suits her husband.  The lie consists not only in the claim that nature exists where it has been tolerated and adapted, but what passes for nature in civilization is by its very substance furthest from all nature, its own self-chosen object.  The femininity which appeals to instinct, is always exactly what every woman has to force herself by violence – masculine violence – to be: a she-man.  One need only have perceived, as a jealous male, how such feminine women have their femininity at their finger-tips – deploying it just where needed, flashing their eyes, using their impulsiveness – to know how things stand with the sheltered unconscious, unmarred by intellect.  Just this unscathed purity is the product of the ego, of censorship, of intellect, which is why it submits so unresistingly to the reality principle of the rational order.  Without a single exception feminine natures are conformist.  The fact that Nietzsche's scrutiny stopped short of them, that he took over a second-hand and unverified image of feminine nature from the Christian civilization that he otherwise so thoroughly mistrusted, finally brought his thought under the sway, after all, of bourgeois society.  He fell for the fraud of saying 'the feminine' when talking of women.  Hence the perfidious advice not to forget the whip: femininity itself is already the effect of the whip.  The liberation of nature would be to abolish its self-fabrication.  Glorification of the feminine character implies the humiliation of all who bear it."

– Theodor Adorno, from Minima Moralia: Reflections from Damaged Life, published in German in 1951, translated by E.F.N. Jephcott and published in English in 1974

Edgar Degas
Portrait of Estelle Balfour (Degas's blind cousin, a war widow)
ca. 1863-65
oil on canvas
Walters Art Museum, Baltimore

Jean-François Millet
Peasant Girl Daydreaming
1848
oil on panel
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Jean-François Millet
Women Sewing by Lamplight
ca. 1853-54
oil on panel
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Alphonse Legros
Head of a Man
1876-77
oil on canvas
Victoria & Albert Museum

Ernest Meissonier
Two Soldiers
1849
oil on panel
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Camille Pissarro
Turkey Girl
1884
tempera on paper
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Pierre Puvis de Chavannes
Hope
1872
oil on canvas
Walters Art Museum, Baltimore

Édouard Manet
Portrait of René Maizeroy
ca. 1882
pastel
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston

Édouard Manet
Music Lesson
1870
oil on canvas
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston