Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Salvator Rosa (1615-1673) - Proto-Romantic Landscapes

Salvator Rosa
Finding of Moses
ca. 1660-65
oil on canvas
Detroit Institute of Arts

Salvator Rosa
Finding of Moses
(detail of figure group)
ca. 1660-65
oil on canvas
Detroit Institute of Arts

"A man of brilliant talent, but a rebel in perpetuity, remorseless in his criticism of society, obsessed by a pre-romantic egotistic conception of genius, Salvator Rosa took offence at being acclaimed as a painter of landscapes, marines, and battle-pieces.  But it is on his achievement in this field rather than on his great historical compositions that his posthumous fame rests.  True to the Italian theoretical approach, he regarded these 'minor' genres as a frivolous pastime.  On the other hand, they gave him the chance of letting his hot temper run amok.  Setting out from the Flemish landscape tradition of Paul and Mattheus Bril, many of his landscapes have their skies dark and laden, storms twist and turn the trees, melancholy lies over the crags and cliffs, buildings crumple into ruins, and banditti linger waiting for their prey.  Painted with a tempestuous brownish and grey palette, these wild scenes were regarded as the opposite to Claude's enchanted elysiums.  The eighteenth century saw in Salvator's and Claude's landscapes the quintessential contrast between the sublime and the beautiful.  In Sir Joshua Reynolds's words, Claude conducts us 'to the tranquility of Arcadian scenes and fairy land,' while Rosa's style possesses 'the power of inspiring sentiments of grandeur and sublimity.'"

"Yet it must be emphasized that the romantic quality of Rosa's landscapes is superimposed on a classical structure, a recipe of 'landscape making' which he shares with the classicists.  Landscape with the Finding of Moses [directly above] shows the repoussoir trunk and tree left and right in the foreground, the classical division into three distances, the careful balancing of light and dark areas.  In addition, the arc of the group of figures fits harmoniously into the undulating terrain, is 'protected' by the larger arc of the tree, and given prominence by the silvery storm-clouds of the background.  Based on accepted formulas, such landscapes were carefully devised in the studio; they are, moreover, 'landscapes of thought,' because more often than not the figures belong to mythology or the Bible and tie the genre, sometimes by a tender link, to the great tradition of Italian painting."

– Rudolf Wittkower, Art and Architecture in Italy 1600-1750, originally published in 1958, revised by Joseph Connors and Jennifer Montagu and reissued by Yale University Press in 1999

Salvator Rosa
Landscape with Travelers asking the way
1641
oil on canvas
National Gallery, London

Salvator Rosa
Landscape with Armed Men
ca. 1640
oil on canvas
Los Angeles County Museum of Art

Salvator Rosa
Landscape with Armed Men
ca. 1640
oil on canvas
Los Angeles County Museum of Art

Salvator Rosa
Landscape with Mercury and the Dishonest Woodman
ca. 1663
oil on canvas
National Gallery, London

Salvator Rosa
Pythagoras emerging from the Underworld
1662
oil on canvas
Kimbell Art Museum, Fort Worth, Texas

Salvator Rosa
The Good Samaritan
before 1673
oil on panel
York City Art Gallery (Yorkshire)

Salvator Rosa
Rocky Landscape with Figures
before 1673
oil on canvas
University of Edinburgh

Salvator Rosa
Mountain Landscape
before 1673
oil on canvas
Southampton City Art Gallery (Hampshire)

Salvator Rosa
Polycrates and the Fisherman
ca. 1664
oil on canvas
Art Institute of Chicago

Salvator Rosa
Polycrates' Crucifixion
ca. 1664
oil on canvas
Art Institute of Chicago

Salvator Rosa
Landscape with Bathers
ca. 1660
oil on canvas
Yale University Art Gallery

Salvator Rosa
St John the Baptist preaching in the Wilderness
ca. 1660
oil on canvas
Saint Louis Art Museum