Friday, March 6, 2020

Tight Compositions in Paint - Before 1900

Thomas Jones
Buildings in Naples
1782
oil on paper
National Museum Cardiff (Wales)

Thomas Gainsborough
Portrait of Mary Robinson
(earliest acknowledged mistress of the Prince Regent)
1781
oil on canvas
National Trust, Waddesdon Manor, Buckinghamshire

Arthur Hughes
Ophelia
1852
oil on canvas
Manchester Art Gallery

Francesco Guardi
Architectural Capriccio
ca. 1770-78
oil on canvas
National Gallery, London

Henri Fantin-Latour
Yellow Roses
1883
oil on canvas
Southampton City Art Gallery

Edwin Landseer
The Monarch of the Glen
1851
oil on canvas
Scottish National Gallery, Edinburgh

William Powell Frith
Prayer
1878
oil on canvas
Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool

"Why is pictorial balance indispensable?  It must be remembered that visually as well as physically, balance is that state of distribution in which all action has come to a standstill.  Potential energy in the system, says the physicist, has reached the minimum.  In a balanced composition all such factors as shape, direction, and location are mutually determined in such a way that no change seems possible, and the whole assumes the character of "necessity" in all its parts.  An unbalanced composition looks accidental, transitory, and therefore invalid.  Its elements show a tendency to change place or shape in order to reach a state that better accords with the total structure.  . . .  Of course balance does not require symmetry.  Symmetry in which, for example, the two wings of a composition are equal is the most elementary manner of creating equilibrium.  More often the artist works with some kind of inequality.  . . .  It is only seemingly paradoxical to assert that disequilibrium can be expressed only by equilibrium, just as disorder can be shown only by order, or separateness by connection."

– Rudolf Arnheim, Art and Visual Perception (University of California Press, 1954)

Anonymous Flemish Artist
Wrestlers
17th century
oil on panel
York City Art Gallery

William Etty
Bound Model
ca. 1828-30
oil on panel
York City Art Gallery

Hugh Hutton Stannus
Head and Shoulders of an Angel
(cartoon for decoration of St Paul's Cathedral)
1880
oil and tempera on canvas
Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool

Peter Paul Rubens
The Bounty of King James I triumphing over Avarice
(sketch for decoration of the Banqueting House ceiling)
ca. 1632-33
oil on panel
Courtauld Gallery, London

Henry Stacy Marks
A Select Committee
1891
oil on canvas
Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool

Anonymous French Artist
Study of a Sculpture of the Head of Jupiter
ca. 1800-1820
oil on canvas
National Trust, Hatchlands, Surrey

George Dawe
The Demoniac
ca. 1811
oil on canvas
Royal Academy of Arts, London
 
Petrus Christus
Man of Sorrows
ca. 1450
oil on panel
Birmingham Museum and Art Gallery, West Midlands