Sunday, July 4, 2021

The Meaner Sort

Anonymous Photographer
Metalworker, USA
ca. 1840-60
hand-colored daguerreotype
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

David Octavius Hill and Robert Adamson
Newhaven Fishermen
ca. 1843-47
carbon print
Scottish National Gallery, Edinburgh

Anonymous Photographer
Laundress, France
1848-50
hand-colored daguerreotype
Getty Museum, Los Angeles

Anonymous Photographer
Three Shepherds
ca. 1850-60
hand-colored daguerreotype
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

Joseph Cundall
Drummer, Great Britain
ca. 1856
salted paper print from glass negative
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

Hugh Welch Diamond
Asylum Patient, Surrey
ca. 1850-58
albumen silver print
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

Anonymous Photographer
Chamber Footman, Russia
ca. 1875-80
albumen print
Hermitage, Saint Petersburg

Wilhelm Lapré
The Courier, Nikolai Nesterov
ca. 1882
albumen print
Hermitage, Saint Petersburg

August Sander
Blacksmiths, Germany
1926
gelatin silver print
Tate Gallery, London

Lisette Model
Peanut Vendor, Nice
ca. 1933-38
gelatin silver print
Getty Museum, Los Angeles

Robert Frank
Men's Room, Railway Station, Memphis, Tennessee
1955-56
gelatin silver print
Art Institute of Chicago

Danny Lyon
Boy with Dog, Knoxville, Tennessee
1967
gelatin silver print
Art Institute of Chicago

Jonas Dovydenas
Adolescent Boy, Manchester, Kentucky
1971
gelatin silver print
Minneapolis Institute of Art

Miroslav Tichý
Shopkeeper, Czechoslovakia 
ca. 1975
photograph
Tichý Ocean Foundation, Prague

Marketa Luskacova
Woman and Man with Bread
Spitalfields, London

1976
gelatin silver print
Tate Gallery, London

"One is concerned with what prevents representation as much as what allows it; one studies blindness as much as vision.  . . .  There are silences which demand explanation, just as there are statements which ask to be ignored.  . . .  In The Golden Bowl Henry James puts the matter thus – Charlotte has just expressed delight in the shopkeeper who has served the heroes – "The Prince was to reply to this that he himself hadn't looked at him; as, precisely, in the general connexion, Charlotte had more than once, from other days noted, for his advantage, her consciousness of how, below a certain social plane, he never saw . . . .  He took throughout, always, the meaner sort for granted – the night of their meanness or whatever name one might give it for him made all his cats grey."

– T.J. Clark, from Image of the People: Gustave Courbet and the Second French Empire, 1848-1851 (New York Graphic Society, 1973)